Added: December 18, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:31 pm.

Present: Deputy Chair Donna Bernard, Members Simon Williams and
Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: Member Paul LaPierre.
Public Present: Corey Benjamin, Carisa Benjamin and Chad Benjamin.

Agenda Item 2: Acceptance of the Minutes for September 7, 2023

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of October 5, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Special Use Permit Extension Request for Parcel ID # 130.00-4-2, 2 acres,
Rural Residential owned by C&C Excavating.
Represented by Corey and Chad Benjamin.

Mr. Corey Benjamin approached the board to request an extension on his special use permit. He explained that between covid and the influx of work post covid, they have not been able to begin the work to the property. Ms. Bernard asked if anything had changed with the plans and their reply was no. Mr. Williams asked if they had an anticipated start date and they said the spring of 2024, they will begin working on the bins for materials and constructing self-storage units. Chair Schobel brought up the lighting on the property and said that it was not in the original plans. Mr. Chad Benjamin said that the lights had been there for a long time.

Chair Schobel stated that the lights are too bright and too high. She recommended that they tip the lighting downward and reach out to Central Hudson for a different style bulb. The height of the lighting was also discussed as the code enforcement officer is suggesting nothing higher than 12 feet. Both Mr. Cory and Chad Benjamin stated that they need the light for when their trucks come back and its dark, claiming that their employees need the light to be able to see and get into their own vehicles at the end of the day. They agreed to call Central Hudson to find out about lighting options.

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously, the board moved to grant the special use permit extension with the following conditions:

1-Through approval with the Code Enforcement Officer, current suggestion 12 feet above ground.

2- This extension for 1 year will be the last.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, Williams and Hopstock. Mr. LaPierre was absent.

Agenda Item 4: Special Use Permit Extension Request for Parcel ID # 131.00-1-27.12,
29.25 acres, Conservation owned by Lakeland Home, LLC.
Represented by Robert Fitzpatrick and Louise Levy.

The board reviewed the site plan and discussed the case.

Mr. Hopstock made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to grant the special use permit with the following conditions:

Extension for special use permit for 1 year effective today, November 2, 2023, with the condition that the foundation is installed before November 1, 2024.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, Williams and Hopstock. Mr. LaPierre was absent.

Agenda Item 6: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

Agenda Item 7: Other Business

Chair Schobel wanted to share with the board that she met with Mr. Brewer during the week and checked the map of Buckley/ O’Bryan lot line adjustment against the mylar and they were the same. There being no other business, Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by

Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 8:12pm.

________________________________Planning Board Chair

________________________________Planning Board Secretary

Added: November 15, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:31 pm.

Present: Deputy Chair Donna Bernard, Members Paul LaPierre and
Simon Williams.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: Member Christopher Hopstock.
Public Present: Steven Sibbern, L.S., Czeslawa E. Kalinski, Marek Kalinski and
Donald Brewer, PLS.

Agenda Item 2: Acceptance of the Minutes for September 7, 2023

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of September 7, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Sketch Plan Review for Parcel ID # 128.00-7-21, 11.93 acres,
Rural Conservation owned by Czeslawa Ewa.
Represented by Donald Brewer Land Surveying, LLC.

Mr. Brewer approached the board and explained that his client is applying to subdivide her parcel that is already physically divided by another parcel. Currently the parcel
has 11.93 acres. It would be broken up into two separate lots, lot #1 would have 3.471 acres and lot #2 would have 8.462 acres.

The board reviewed the application and found it was complete along with the fee being paid. After reviewing the sketch plan, the board agreed to go to the next stage.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously,

The board moved to declare lead agency status for this unlisted action.

The Planning Board then preliminarily completed the SEQR part 2 and 3 and instructed the secretary to send the referral to Cynthia Garcia, SEQR Coordinator.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to approve the sketch plan.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to hold a public hearing for Parcel ID #128.00-7-21 at the next planning board meeting which has been scheduled for November 2, 2023 at 7:30pm.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, LaPierrre and Williams. Mr. Hopstock was absent.

The planning board secretary will place the ad in the Mountain Eagle Newspaper regarding the public hearing.

Agenda Item 4: Altered Lot Line for Parcel ID # 130.00-4-53, 5.10 acres owned by Michael Wagner and Parcel ID # 130.00-4-55, 5.70 acres owned by Robert Pair. Rural Conservation.
Represented by Donald Brewer Surveying, LLC.

Mr. Brewer explained to the board that his clients who boarder each other’s property have realized that Mr. Wagner’s septic field area is on his neighbor, Mr. Pear’s property.

Mr. Brewer said that adjusting the lot line would correct this issue.

The Planning Board reviewed the application and found it to be complete.

However, Mr. Brewer did not have the $200 fee. He was told by the planning board to come to the townhouse during the week to drop off the check. Mr. Brewer agreed.

The board reviewed the sketch plan. They saw that there will be an equal exchange of property and all acreage amounts will stay the same.

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unaniomously, the board moved to approve the altered lot line.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, LaPierrre and Williams. Mr. Hopstock was absent.

Agenda Item 5: Altered Lot Line for Parcel ID # 147.00-1-2, 189 acres owned by
Stephen and Kelly O’Bryan and Parcel ID #147.00-1-1.1, 66.7 acres owned by Peter Buckley. Rural Residential. Represented by Donald Brewer Surveying, LLC.

Mr. Brewer presented himself to the board once again and explained that the reason for his clients altered lot line application is because it is part of a court order which reads, “Upon completion of the survey, defendants will secure a lot line adjustment from the town of Jewett Planning Board to annex the 25 acre parcel to their remaining land bearing the tax map # 147.00-1-1.1.” The board reviewed the application and found it to be complete. The fee was not paid and Mr. Brewer was instructed to bring the amount with him when he comes to drop off the other fee. The board reviewed the map.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the altered lot line by way of the Greene County Court.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, LaPierrre and Williams. Mr. Hopstock was absent.

Agenda Item 6: Public Hearing for Minor Subdivision for Parcel ID # 129.00-5-2.1, 36.7 acres,
Rural Residential owned by Andrew Gilbert and Kathleen Lawler.
Represented by Sibbern Land Surveying.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to open the public hearing at 8:10pm.

No public comments were made.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to close the public hearing at 8:10pm.

Agenda Item 5: Application for Minor Subdivision for Parcel ID # 129.00-5-2.1, 36.7 acres,
Rural Residential owned by Andrew Gilbert and Kathleen Lawler.
Represented by Sibbern Land Surveying.

The board found that Mr. Sibbern’s application was complete along with the fee being paid. The board then reviewed comments received from Cynthia Garcia, SEQRA coordinator stating that the DEP does not object to the Planning Board acting as Lead Agency for the coordinated review of the proposed action pursuant to the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA).

The board did a preliminary review last month regarding part 1 and 2 of the SEQR review. The board then reviewed part 3, the determination of significance.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously, the board moved to declare a negative declaration.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, LaPierrre and Williams. Mr. Hopstock was absent.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to approve Andrew Gilbert and Kathleen Lawler’s application for minor subdivision for Parcel ID #129.00-5-2.1.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, LaPierrre and Williams. Mr. Hopstock was absent.

Agenda Item 6: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

Agenda Item 7: Other Business

There being no other business, Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 9:10pm.

________________________________Planning Board Chair

________________________________Planning Board Secretary

Added: October 10, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:32 pm.

Present: Deputy Chair Donna Bernard, Members Paul LaPierre and
Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: Member Simon Williams.
Public Present: Steven Sibbern, L.S., Ron San Fillipo and Bill Rod.

Agenda Item 2: Acceptance of the Minutes for August 3, 2023

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of August 3, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Sketch Plan Review for Parcel ID # 129.00-5-2.1, 36.70 acres, Rural Residential owned by Andrew Gilbert and Kathleen Lawler. Represented by Sibbern Land Surveying.

Mr. Sibbern approached the board and showed his revisions to the sketch plan.

He adjusted the boundary lot line so that it is 50’ away from the existing barn on the property and meets zoning code. This boundary lot line adjustment resulted in the new lot being 3.682 acres instead of originally being 3.522 acres.

At the previous planning board meeting, Chair Schobel requested that Mr. Sibbern bring a copy of the deed to make sure there are no restrictions on the property and it was found that there were none. Deputy Chair Bernard also requested Mr. Sibbern double check on wetlands other than Conifer Lake. Mr. Sibbern reported that the current lot is 250’ away from the pond and the new lot will be 450’ away from the pond.

The board then reviewed the application and found it was complete along with the fee being paid. After reviewing the sketch plan, the board agreed to go to the next stage.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously,

The board moved to declare lead agency status for this unlisted action.

The Planning Board then preliminarily completed the SEQR part 2 and 3 and instructed the secretary to send the referral to Cynthia Garcia, SEQR Coordinator.

Mr. Hopstock made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to hold a public hearing for Parcel ID #129.00-5-2.1 at the next planning board meeting which has been scheduled for October 5, 2023 at 7:30pm.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, LaPierrre and Hopstock. Mr. Williams was absent.

The planning board secretary will place the ad in the Mountain Eagle Newspaper regarding the public hearing.

Agenda Item 4: Public Hearing for Minor Subdivision for Parcel ID # 111.00-2-49, 8.92 acres,
Rural Residential owned by Peter J & Kevin P Brabazon Trustees of the Margaret Fromm Irrevocable Trust. Represented by Ron San Fillipo.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to open the public hearing at 8:02pm.

No public comments were made.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously, the board moved to close the public hearing at 8:06pm.

Agenda Item 5: Application for Minor Subdivision for Parcel ID # 111.00-2-49, 8.92 acres,
Rural Residential owned by Peter J & Kevin P Brabazon Trustees of the Margaret Fromm Irrevocable Trust. Represented by Ron San Fillipo.

The board reviewed comments received from Cynthia Garcia, SEQRA coordinator stating that the DEP does not object to the Planning Board acting as Lead Agency for the coordinated review of the proposed action pursuant to the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA).

The board did a preliminary review last month regarding part 1 and 2 of the SEQR review. The board then reviewed part 3, the determination of significance.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously, the board moved to declare a negative declaration.

Roll Call: AYE, Schobel, Bernard, LaPierre and Hopstock. Absent was Mr. Williams.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously the board moved to approve Peter J & Kevin P Brabazon Trustees of the Margaret Fromm Irrevocable Trust Application for Minor Subdivision for Parcel ID #111.00-2-49, 8.92 acres.

Roll Call: AYE, Schobel, Bernard, LaPierre and Hopstock. Absent was Mr. Williams.

Mr. SanFillipo did not have his fee of $500 nor a mylar copy of the sketch plan for the Planning Board Chair to sign. He will stop by the townhouse during the week with his fee and mylar copy so that it can be signed and then filed with Greene County.

Agenda Item 6: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

Agenda Item 7: Other Business

There being no other business, Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 8:25pm.

________________________________Planning Board Chair

________________________________Planning Board Secretary

Added: September 11, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:27 pm.

Present: Deputy Chair Donna Bernard, Members Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and
Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: None
Public Present: Andrew Wrabel, Steven Sibbern, L.S., Ron San Fillipo, C. Kalinski, Bill Rod and Greg Kroyer.

Agenda Item 2: Acceptance of the Minutes for July 6, 2023

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of July 6, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Minor Subdivision/ Sketch Plan Review for Parcel ID # 128.00-7-21, 11.93 acres, Rural Conservation owned by Czeslawa Ewa Kalinski.

Mrs. Kalinski came before the board to apply to subdivide her property. The property is located both in the Town of Jewett and the Town of Lexington. While Mrs. Kalinski had a filled out application and $200 for the fee, she was missing site maps, The Short Environmental Assessment Form Part 1 and was told she needed to contact a surveyor. She agreed to have everything before the next planning board meeting which is scheduled for September 7, 2023.

Agenda Item 4: Minor Subdivision/ Sketch Plan Review for Parcel ID # 129.00-5-2.1, 36.70 acres, Rural Residential owned by Andrew Gilbert and Kathleen Lawler.
Represented by Sibbern Land Surveying.

Mr. Sibbern approached the board and showed his client’s plans to subdivide their property. They own 36.7 acres and are looking to subdivide 3.522 acres from the parcel.

The board reviewed the application and found it was complete along with the fee being paid.

Chair Schobel asked Mr. Sibbern to bring a copy of the deed for next month’s meeting to make sure there are no restrictions. Mr. Sibbern agreed.

Ms. Bernard noticed on the Short Environmental Assessment Form Mapper Summary Report that wetlands had been identified and asked if there were wetlands on the property.

Mr. Sibbern said it was Confier Lake. Ms. Bernard asked him to double check on wetlands other than Conifer Lake. Mr. Sibbern agreed. They then discussed the case and reviewed the maps.

On the site map, the board saw an existing shed that is on the proposed new parcel to be only 20 ft. from the new property line. Due to zoning codes, it must be 50ft. away.

Mr. Sibbern agreed to change the boundary line for next month’s meeting.

Agenda Item 5: Minor Subdivision/ Sketch Plan Review for Parcel ID # 111.00-2-49, 8.92 acres,
Rural Residential owned by Peter J & Kevin P Brabazon Trustees of the Margaret Fromm Irrevocable Trust. Represented by Ron San Fillipo.

The board reviewed the application and found it was complete along with the fee being paid. They reviewed the site maps and found it was eligible to go to the next stage.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously,

The board moved to declare lead agency status for this unlisted action.

The Planning Board then preliminarily completed the SEQR part 2 and 3 and instructed the secretary to send the referral to Cynthia Garcia, SEQR Coordinator.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously, the board moved to go forward with a public hearing for The Margaret Fromm Irrevocable Trust’s minor subdivision at the next planning board meeting which is scheduled for September 7, 2023 at 7:30pm.

Roll Call Vote: AYE Schobel, Bernard, LaPierrre, Williams and Hopstock.

The secretary will place a legal ad in The Mountain Eagle regarding the public hearing.

Mr. SanFillipo was then furnished with the public hearing signs along with instructions on how to post and a letter form that is to be sent to adjoining property owners thru certified mail regarding the Subdivision Public Hearing. He was also given the names and address of all those that he must notify. Mr. SanFillipo received a certification form of posting public hearing notice sign and a certification form of mailing notices of public hearing to adjoining property owners.

Agenda Item 6: Review of Solar Moratorium

On a motion by Ms. Bernard, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to send a letter of recommendation to the Town Board regarding their final draft of the proposed Solar Moratorium and Pilot Law.

Agenda Item 4: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

Agenda Item 5: Other Business

There being no other business, Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 8:58pm.

________________________________Planning Board Chair

________________________________Planning Board Secretary

Added: August 07, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:35 pm.

Present: Deputy Chair Donna Bernard, Members Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and
Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: None
Public Present: Andrew Wrabel and Bill Rod.

Agenda Item 2: Acceptance of the Minutes for June 1, 2023

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of June 1, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Review of Solar Moratorium

The planning board did a side by side review of the town’s current solar law and the new one that they have been working on to make sure everything in the current solar law has been addressed. The board also reviewed the “Solar Energy System Pilot Law”, a separate law that addresses real property taxes.

Agenda Item 4: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

Agenda Item 5: Other Business

Chair Schobel shared with the board a possible pending case for a minor subdivision for Parcel ID # 128.00-7-21, 11.93 acres, Rural Conservation owned by Czeslawa Ewa Kalinski.

The board reviewed the property on the map and discussed the steps that the property owner would need to take.

There being no other business, Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 8:55pm.

________________________________Planning Board Chair

________________________________Planning Board Secretary

Added: July 11, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm.

Present: Deputy Chair Donna Bernard, Members Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and
Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: None
Public Present: Doug Van Deusen of LaMont Engineers, Ryan Cornelison of Stinemire Engineering, Andrew Wrabel and Bill Rod.

Agenda Item 2: Acceptance of the Minutes for May 4, 2023

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of May 4, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Major Subdivision Birch Woods Subdivision for Parcel ID # 129.00-3-4,

68.60 acres, Rural Residential, owned by Ferdinand Kuznik, represented by Ryan Cornelison, P.E. of Stinemire Engineering.

Mr. Cornelison, P.E took the floor and related to the board all the changes that were made to the plans since he was last there. Comments from the Jewett Planning Board, Jewett Town Board, Jewett Town Highway Department, NYCDEP, NYSDEC, US Army Corps of Engineers, Greene County Planning Board 239 Review and Greene County Highway Department were all taken into consideration while the plans were being updated. The board listened to the changes and asked questions.

On a motion by Planning Board Member LaPierre, 2nd by Planning Board Member Hopstock and carried, The Board adopted the following resolution. SUBJECT: TOWN OF JEWETT RESOLUTION, FINDINGS AND DECISION BIRCH WOOD MAJOR SUBDIVISION APPLICATION FINAL PLAT APPROVAL, APRIL 6, 2023.

I. WHEREAS,

  1. On or about September 13, 2022, Birch Wood Development LLC, (hereinafter referred to as the “Applicant” or “Birch Wood”) applied to the Planning Board of the Town of Jewett for approval of a 12-lot major subdivision of a parcel of land located on County Route 77, also known as Hesley Road, Town of Jewett (Tax Map Number 129.00-3-3.1) and is located in an RR (Rural Residential) Zone as that term is defined in the Town of Jewett Zoning Law.
  1. Initially, the Applicant sought approval of the subdivision of the two lots into 13 total lots, consisting of 12 single family. The Applicant will be applying to the NYS Department of State of approval of homeowner’s association for ownership of the roads and drainage and other facilities and infrastructure within the development.

All of the proposed lots will be served by on-site wells and septic systems. Access to the proposed lots will be by a proposed private road to be constructed. The private road will be constructed in accordance with the Highway Specifications in the Town of Jewett, with the exception that the road will not have a paved surface. The road design was reviewed with the Town of Jewett Highway Superintendent. Initially, the road will owned and maintained by a Home Owners’ Association (HOA) to be formed by the Applicant and approved by the State of New York but may be dedicated to the Town as a Town Highway at a point in the future when appropriate.

  1. The Planning Board received and reviewed the following submissions from the Applicant and the Town’s independent engineer, Lamont Engineers, during the review process, all of which are incorporated herein by reference:

STINEMIRE ENGINEERS:

  • Birch Woods Application Package dated 1-10-23:
    • Authorization letter (9-6-2022) from the Owner for Stinemire Engineering to act as Client’s Agent
    • Completed Town of Jewett Application for Major Subdivision
    • Response letter to Town’s Engineer – comments on Sketch Plan Submission
    • Completed Full EAF (FEAF) – Part-1 with NYSDEC EAF Mapper Summary Report signed by John Stinemire, PE – Stinemire Engineering, PC, dated 1-10-22
    • List of adjacent Property Owners
    • Property Deed
    • Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) Report dated January 2023
    • Preliminary Subdivision Project Drawings
  • Birch Woods Application Package – February 22, 2023:
    • Authorization letter (9-6-2022) to act as Owner’s representative
    • Completed Town of Jewett Application for Major Subdivision
    • Response letter dated 2-22-2023 to Town Planning Board RE- Response comments to January Preliminary Submission
    • Completed Full EAF (FEAF) – Part-1 with NYSDEC EAF Mapper Summary Report
    • List of adjacent Property Owners
    • Certification of Mailing Notices (copies of certified receipts) for Public Hearing to Adjoining Property Owners by Stinemire Engineering dated 2-16-23
    • USPS Proof of Delivery summary dated 2-10-23
    • NYCDEP Letter dated 1-30-23_ Notice of Incomplete Application – SSTS (Subsurface Sewage Treatment System)
    • NYCDEP Letter dated 1- 30-23_ Notice of Incomplete Application – SWPPP (Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan)
    • Email from Ryan Mayer – USACOE dated Jan. 24, 2023 RE- ACOE review of project design development with request for additional information
    • Stinemire Engineering letter dated 2-10-23; RE – ACOE response comments, photos, photo key map, etc. to Mr. Mayer
    • NYS Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation letter dated 2-03-23 RE- SHPO response to inquiry concerning Historic / Cultural Resources with CRIS map
    • Preliminary Subdivision Project Drawings revised to 2-22-23
    • Completed Full EAF (FEAF) Part-1 dated 2/22/23, signed by John Stinemire, PE – Stinemire Engineering, PC
  • Birch Woods Application Package – March 29, 2023:
    • Authorization letter (9-6-22) to act as Owner’s representative
    • Stinemire Engineering letter dated 3-29-23 to Curt Field (NYCDEP) RE- NYCDEP project review comments (SWPPP & SSTS)
    • Preliminary Subdivision Drawings revised to 3/29/23
    • Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) revised to March 2023

LAMONT ENGINEERS:

  • Sketch Plan – Preliminary Review Comments _ 10-6-22
  • Preliminary Project Review comments (Lamont Ltr)_ 1-26-23
  • Email _ Lamont Engineers to Town PB Chairperson RE-Notes from 2-2-23 PB Mtg_ 2-3-23
  • Preliminary Submission Review Comments (Lamont Ltr)_ 2-25-23
  • January Planning Board Mtg Notes – Lamont Eng’rs _ 2-3-23
  • EMAIL _ Lamont to Town RE- Notes of discussions from Feb. 22, 2023 PB Mtg.
  • Preliminary Submission Review Comments (Lamont Ltr for 3-29-23 revised plan submission_ 3-31-23
  • Copy – Town’s Public Hearing Sign-In Sheet for 3-2-23
  • Preliminary Project Review Comments (letter) dated 3-31-23 for Project review at 4-6-23 PB meeting

NYCDEP:

  • NYCDEP Ltr dated 1-30-23 RE- Birch Woods SSTS Notice of Incomplete Application
  • NYCDEP Ltr dated 1-30-23 RE- Birch Woods SWPPP Notice of Incomplete Application
  • NYCDEP Ltr dated 2-21-23 RE- Lead Agency Response & Project Comments
  • NYCDEP Ltr dated 4-6-23 RE- Notice of Complete Application SWPPP

ARMY CORPS of ENGINEERS:

  • Email from Ryan Mayer to Stinemire Engineering dated Jan. 24, 2023 RE-ACOE Project Review Comments
  • USACOE – Dept of the Army, US Corps of Engineers letter dated 3/1/23 to Property Owner, Ferdinand Kuznik RE-Notice of Nationwide Permit (# NAN-2023-00065) for Nationwide General Permit # 29, including Nationwide Permit Compliance Certification & Report Form (for certification of completed work when completed)
  1. The Board also received and reviewed, in-depth, the several written and verbal submissions from the public.

E. The following is the procedural history of the project:

Sept 12th 2022 Ryan Cornelison I.E., Stinemire Engineering
E-mail regarding intent to send in an application for a sketch plan review

Sept13th 2022 Ryan Cornelison I.E., Stinemire Engineering
Application received by e-mail, maps dated 9/12/2022
Application for Subdivision – Sketch Plan Review Form (and fee) · Signed authorization to act as client’s agent · Full Environmental Assessment Form, Part 1 · List of adjacent property owners · Property Deed · Sketch Subdivision Plans

October 6th 2022 Doug Van Deusen, Sr. Project Manager, Lamont Engineers
Preliminary review comments for the SKETCH PLAN submission

October 6th 2022 Planning Board Meeting
Sketch Plan Review Parcel ID # 129.00-3-4, 68.60 acres, owned by Ferdinand Kuznik, represented by Ryan Cornelison I.E.,of Stinemire Engineering

Jan 10th, 2023 Application received by e-mail
Authorization to act as client’s agent Town of Jewett Application for Major Subdivision · Response Letter to Town Engineer’s comments on Sketch Plan Submission · Full Environmental Assessment Form – Part 1 · List of adjacent property owners · Property Deed · Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) Report · Preliminary Subdivision Project Drawings
Preliminary Plan Submission dated January 9, 2023 by the Developer’s Consultant – Stinemire Engineering, P.C. on behalf of Owners / Developers Mr. Kuznik and Mr. Oliynyk.

January 10th 2023 Ryan Cornelison I.E., Stinemire Engineering
Developer’s Consultant has submitted the onsite sanitary wastewater treatment/disposal system(s) and Stormwater Treatment / Management system to NYCDEP for their review and comment

January 28th, 2023 Doug Van Deusen, Sr. Project Manager, Lamont Engineers, P.C.
Attached is our project review summary for the Birch Woods – 12 Lot Major Subdivision located on CR-77 in the Town of Jewett. The review is based on the materials submitted for Preliminary Plan review dated January 10, 2023, on behalf of Owners / Developers Mr. Kuznik and Mr. Oliynyk.
January 30th, 2023 Curt Field
Associate Project Manager | NYC Environmental Protection
Bureau of Water Supply | Regulatory & Engineering Programs
Please find the attached Subsurface Sewage Treatment System (SSTS) Notice of Incomplete Applications (NOICA), from Curtis Field, NYCDEP

February 2nd 2023 Planning Board Meeting

The Board revisited/recapped the October 6, 2022 mtg such that the mtg record of 2/2/23 reflects that the Planning Brd accepted the application for the Birch Woods Major Subdivision. Based on the materials submitted, the Brd voted (2/2/23) to approve the submission for Sketch Plan

Planning Board went over comments and discussion items reflected in Lamont Engineers project review letter dated 1/26/23 and discussion of materials submitted by Stinemire Eng’rg.

PB went thru FEAF Part-1 at the February meeting

February 6th 2023 Town Clerk, Town of Jewett

As part of a coordinated review between the Town of Jewett Planning Board, Town of Jewett Town Board, letters were sent out to the list below. The Town of Jewett is seeking lead agency status.

NYCDEP, Cynthia Garcia
NYSDEC, Ms. Kornak
US Army Corps of Engineers
Greene County Planning Board, 239 Review
Greene County Highway Department

2/21/23 NYC DEP
SEQRA response letter in regard to the above referenced action.

2/22/23 Email from Ryan Cornelison. He has attached their revised submission.

2/26/23 Doug Van Deusen, Sr. Project Manager, Lamont Engineers, P.C.
Reviewed the application, FEAF, plans, details, and questions / comments, etc. the Board determined the Preliminary Plan as submitted was detailed enough to schedule at least the first Public Hearing for March 2nd, 2023

2/26/23 Doug Van Deusen, Sr. Project Manager, Lamont Engineers, P.C.
Reviewed the revised materials provided by Stinemire Engineering dated February 22, 2023 along with correspondence from NYCDEP and US Army Corps of Engineers (ACOE) and offered his comments

March 1st 2023 USACOE dated 3/1/23
Response letter
March 2nd 2023 Tal G. Rappleyea, Attorney at Law
First draft. Conditions of approval

March 2nd 2023 Doug Van Deusen, Sr. Project Manager, Lamont Engineers, P.C
Review of draft list of conditions reviewed and list of comments attached.

March 2, 2023 Planning Board Meeting / Public Hearing for the Birch Woods Project:
FEAF Parts 2 and 3 work reviewed and completed

March 7, 2023 Town Clerk, Town of Jewett
Full Environmental Assessment Form Part 2 & 3, completed, signed and sent out to Ryan Cornelison P.E., Stinemire Engineering

March 7, 2023 Curtis Field, NYC DEP
Draft comments based on the January 2023 SWPPP and SSTS submission. These draft comments are in addition to the comments listed in the NOICA dated January 30, 2023.

March 21, 2023 Doug Van Deusen, Sr. Project Manager
Revised draft of Conditions of Final Approval as edited

March 29, 2023 Ryan Cornelison P.E., Stinemire Engineering
Received revised SWPPP Report and Drawings for the Birch Woods Subdivision.
April 6th 2023 Planning board meeting / Public hearing closed
April 3, 2023 Doug Van Deusen, Sr. Project Manager, Lamont Engineers
Attached is our review comment letter for the Birch Woods Major Subdivision

April 5th, 2023 Doug Van Deusen, Sr. Project Manager, Lamont Engineers
Edited summary of DRAFT “Conditions of Approval” that incorporate items that were discussed during a conference call Mr. Van Deusen had with Greg (Kroyer) and Robert (Mallory)

April 6th, 2023 Curt Field | | NYC DEP
Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) Notice of Complete Applications (NOCA) for the Birch Woods Subdivision project. Determination to be decided on May 21, 2023

June 1, 2023

Planning Board issues final approval with final conditions of approval

F. The application is consistent with the currently adopted Jewett Town Subdivision Law and Zoning Law. All proposed lots are larger than the minimum lot size allowed in the district. The current character of the surrounding community is that of rural residential home sites. Further, the Town Subdivision Law allows for a much greater density of development than that which is proposed.

In accordance with the notices published during the several month period during which the review process was conducted, the Board examined both the SEQRA issues and the approval process. The continuous participation of the public resulted in numerous modifications of the preliminary plat that resulted in a vastly improved project that has no significant environmental impacts and is in harmony with the Town Local Laws.

II. WHEREAS

A. Under Article 140 of the Jewett Town Code and its amendments generally and in §§140-3 and 140-15, thereof specifically details the required contents of plats and standards by which major subdivisions must be measured and preliminary plat approval may be granted. Those sections read as follows:

“§140-3 Policy

It is declared to be the policy of the Planning Board to consider land subdivisions as part of a plan for the orderly, efficient, and economical development of the Town. This means, among other things:

A. That land to be subdivided shall be of such character that it can be used safely for building purposes without danger of health or peril from fire, flood, or other menace, and without resulting in significant and/or irreparable damage to the ecology of the area in which it is located;

B. That proper provisions shall be made for surface drainage, water supply, sewage and improvements;

C. That all proposed lots shall be so laid out and of such size as to not cause any adverse effects, such as erosion, on neighboring properties or roadways;

D. In order to facilitate fire protection, roads shall have a minimum width (50 feet), grade and location so as to accommodate the prospective traffic. Roads shall also follow the natural contours of the land.

§140-15. Preliminary plat and accompanying data.

Five copies of the major subdivision preliminary plat shall be submitted at a scale of not more than 100 feet but preferably not less than 50 feet to the inch. The plat shall be clearly marked “Major Subdivision Preliminary plat.,’

A. Requirements. In addition to the data in the sketch plan, the preliminary plat application shall include the following:

(1) Proposed subdivision name, name of Town and county in which it is located, date, North point, scale, name and address of record owner, subdivider and engineer or surveyor including license number and seal.

(2) The name of all subdivisions immediately adjacent and the names of the owners of record of all property adjacent to the subdivision and within 500 feet of any perimeter boundary.

(3) Offers of cession of all land to be offered for dedication for roads, highways, easements, parks or other public facilities.

(4) The location of all existing property lines, easements, structures, water bodies, watercourses, wetlands, flood hazard areas, rock outcrops, wooded areas and any other significant existing features that may influence the design of the proposed subdivision.

(5) Accurate topographic mapping at a vertical contour interval of 10 feet or less as required by the Planning Board.

(6) Location of existing sewers, water mains, culverts and drains on the property, with pipe sizes, grades, direction of flow and existing easements.

(7) The width, location and names of any roads or public ways or places within the area to be subdivided and the right-of-way width, location grades, and proposed easements of all roads or public ways proposed by the developer.

(8) Approximate location and size of all proposed water lines and sewer lines or alternative means of water supply or sewage disposal and treatment, including sites for on-site systems as provided in the Public Health Law. If individual septic systems are proposed, soil percolation tests shall be performed for each proposed building lot. The results of these soil tests shall accompany the major subdivision preliminary plat.

(9) Storm drainage plan indicating the approximate location and size of proposed lines, their profiles and connection to existing and proposed drainage easements. Temporary measures to control erosion during construction phase shall also be shown.

(10) Plans and cross-sections showing the proposed location and type of sidewalks, streetlighting standards, street trees, curbs, water mains, sanitary sewers and storm drains, and the size and type thereof, the character, width and depth of pavements and subbase, the location of manholes, basins and underground conduits.

(11) Preliminary designs of any bridges or culverts which may be required.

(12) The proposed lot lines with approximate dimensions and area of each lot and the total acreage of the subdivision.

(13) Where the topography is such as to make difficult the inclusion of any of the required facilities within the public areas as laid out, the preliminary plat shall show the boundaries of proposed permanent easements over or under private property, which permanent easements shall not be less than 20 feet in width and which shall provide satisfactory access to an existing public road or other public road or public open space shown on the subdivision.

(14) An actual field survey of the boundary lines of the parcel, giving complete descriptive data by bearings and distances, prepared and certified to by a licensed land surveyor. The corners of the tract shall also be located on the ground and marked by substantial monuments of such size and type as approved by the licensed engineer and shall be referenced and shown on the plat.

(15) If the proposed subdivision covers only a part of the subdivider’s entire holding, a map of the entire tract drawn at a scale of not less than 400 feet to the inch showing an outline of the platted area with its proposed roads and indication of the probable future road system with its grades and drainage in the remaining portion of the tract and the probable future drainage layout of the entire tract shall be submitted. The part of the subdivider’s holding submitted shall be considered in light of the entire holdings.

B Covenants and deed restrictions. A copy of such covenants or deed restrictions that are intended to cover any lot in all or part of the tract shall be submitted along with the preliminary plat.

C. SEQR documents. A completed environmental assessment form or draft environmental impact statement, as required by the Planning Board under the NYS Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQR) shall be submitted along with the preliminary plat.”

D. The applicant previously sought and received approval of the Preliminary Plat in accordance with the Town Subdivision Law. The Final Plat was submitted within 6 months of the within Resolution, subject to completion of all appropriate Conditions hereinafter set forth.

E. Additionally the Town Subdivision Law also authorizes the requirement of the posting of a performance bond in a form acceptable to the Attorney for the Town and in an amount acceptable to the Town Engineer to cover cost of all required improvements, which also has been set forth hereinafter. The required improvements covered by the Bond include, but are not limited to, the construction of the road, driveways and drainage facilities.

F. The Jewett Town Subdivision Law requires an examination of subdivisions in accordance with character of land and the Board must make determinations that the property in question can be used safely for building purposes without danger to health or peril from fire, flood or other menace, that the project is in accordance with the Master Plan as implemented by the Planning Board and that all required improvements are made in accordance with Town Specifications. Based upon each of the above delineated items the Board does find that the proposed Preliminary Plat, as amended, meets each of the requirements in that the design of the roadway and driveways make all building locations easily accessible by emergency and fire apparatus, and drainage is more than sufficient to prevent flooding. The project is proposed to be substantially less densely developed than is allowed under the Town Building Law. Additionally, the Board further requires as a condition of approval that the Plat contain a provision that no parcel may be further subdivided. Thus, the Preliminary Plat is consistent with the adopted Master Plan, and

NOW THEREFORE IT IS RESOLVED THAT

A. It is by the above standards and requirements that this Board reviewed the application. Based upon the facts, findings and analysis set forth above, this Board hereby finds that the application of the Applicant fulfills the requirements of the Town Subdivision Law for the granting of a Preliminary Plat approval and final Site Plan Approval for the common lot, provided that the conditions hereinafter set forth are met. Additionally, the Board finds that environmental and other impacts have been examined and mitigated to the greatest extent possible where they have been found to exist.

B. In making this decision, this Board reviewed and considered the entire administrative record of these proceedings and the environmental review hereof.

FINDINGS:

  1. The resulting parcels will comply with all existing bulk requirements in the Town Building Law.
  2. All adjoining landowners of the affected parcel were notified in writing of the public hearing.
  3. The Planning Board declared itself lead agency for the purpose of conducting a SEQRA review.
  4. The application and the survey map submitted contain all necessary information as required under Article 140 of the Town Code of the Town of Jewett, entitled “Subdivision of Land”
  5. The Planning Board took the required “hard look” at the project with regard to the requirements of the NYS Environmental Quality Review Act and found that this action is Type 1 action.

Based upon the above findings the Board determines that:

The application, as amended, for a Preliminary Plat Approval should be and hereby is granted.
Having completed a review of the environmental assessment form submitted by the applicant, and the Board having issued a Negative Declaration, the Board determined that an environmental impact statement need not be prepared.”

RESOLUTION MOTION MADE BY Paul LaPierre,
SECONDED BY Board Member Chris Hopstock.
ROLL CALL:

AYE NAY RECUSED/ABSENT/OTHER

Chairperson Schobel X
Board Member Bernard X
Board Member LaPierre X
Board Member Williams X
Board Member Hopstock X

CARRIED.
DATED: June 1, 2023

Attachments:
Schedule A (Conditions)
Schedule B (SEQRA resolution, Long Form EAF and supplement)
Schedule C (Negative Declaration and Rationale)

SCHEDULE A

The following restrictions will be endorsed on the original Plat Plan of the subdivision and become part of the Planning Board’s approval of the subdivision. These restrictions and covenants will run with the land and be referred to in each of the deeds of the lots within the subdivision.

BIRCH WOODS – MAJOR SUBDIVISION CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL

The following restrictions will be endorsed on the original Plat Plan of the subdivision and become part of the Town Planning Board’s approval of the Major Subdivision. These restrictions and covenants will run with the land and be referred to in each of the deeds of the lots within the subdivision.

1. No Further Subdivision. No lot within the subdivision shall be further subdivided. This does not preclude Lot Line Adjustments or merger of two or more lots provided no new building lot shall be created thereby.

2. The Homeowners Association (HOA), or its successor(s) shall be responsible for the construction and permanent maintenance of all improvements proposed for the project including but not limited to construction of the roadway to town specifications, stormwater and drainage facilities, lot corner monuments, drainage basins, rock check dams, overflow structures, stabilized outlet aprons, etc., as well as all structures and improvements and proposed uses for lot #8 and drainage systems and/or easements associated with drainage management systems. Any maintenance of HOA systems by the Town of Jewett, Greene County Highway Dept., etc. shall be at the expense of the HOA and/or residents of the Development.

3. The HOA shall construct the roadway to town specifications and then shall offer the roadway to the Town as a town highway following the issuance of the third Certificate of Occupancy for homes within the subdivision, in accordance with the Town Highway design requirements and dedication requirements at the time of offering. The Town shall have no obligation to accept the roadway into the Town Highway system.

4. In the future event the HOA fails to or cannot discharge its duties and obligations set forth herein, the property owners of each of the parcels shall be individually and collectively responsible for such duties and obligations. This condition shall be contained in each deed for each parcel within the subdivision. Any maintenance or repairs performed by the Town of Jewett, Greene County, etc. shall be at the expense of the HOA and/or its successors.

5. Building Envelopes. The dwelling and out-buildings on each lot shall be contained entirely within the Town’s minimum set-back requirements as shown on the Subdivision Plat Plan. Accessory structures and recreational facilities shall be situated in accordance with the applicable Local Laws at the time each building permit is secured.

6. The Applicant/Developer shall comply with all Town Codes of the Town of Jewett, including but not limited to Town Subdivision, Site Plan Review, Building Permit, and applicable Local Laws at the time of construction.

7. ANY / ALL tree clearing for any new lot shall be in compliance with existing Town Codes pertaining to forestry management and forestry preservation (Ref. Town Code # 140-29 Preservation of Natural Features).

8. All onsite water and wastewater treatment and disposal systems shall comply with all Local, NYSDEC, NYCDEP, and Federal statutes at time of issuing building permits for construction of residential and/or areas of “Common Use” under the jurisdiction of the HOA.

9. All onsite stormwater management systems shall comply with applicable NYSDEC, NYCDEP, and Federal (USACOE) regulations and design guidelines at time of construction and/or implementation.

10. All building structures to be constructed shall comply with the Town Code for the Town of Jewett at the time of construction and shall comply with NYS and International Fire and Building Code, as well as all applicable Town of Jewett local laws.

11. All outdoor amenities shall be constructed and installed in compliance with the Codes for the Town of Jewett and all applicable Town of Jewett Local Laws at time of construction / installation.

12. All roadway, rights of way (ROW), drainage system maintenance, perpetual management and compliance shall be the absolute responsibility of the Applicant Development Homeowner Association (HOA) on a 24-hours, 7-days per week, 365- days per year basis for all resident and emergency service access. The Town of Jewett shall have absolutely no responsibility for snow removal, drainage system maintenance, and/or roadway maintenance until the roadway has been accepted into the Town of Jewett Highway System. Prior to Town acceptance for dedication into the Town Highway System, the Applicant and/or HOA shall provide a detailed HOA Plan to the Town of Jewett for review and acceptance prior to FINAL APPROVAL. A representative of the HOA shall be available (in-person or by electronic contact (email, text, phone, etc.) during reasonable business hours.

13. Prior to final subdivision approval ALL lots created by the Subdivision shall be properly monumented in accordance with the Town of Jewett Subdivision Local Law, and Highway Specifications in accordance with the Codes for the Town of Jewett. All monumentation shall meet approval of Town Code Enforcement Dept.

14. ANY changes to the number of parcels (lots) proposed (increase or decrease) shall be presented to the Town for review and approval under the applicable Town Local Laws at the time of modification. No parcel shall be combined (un-subdivided) without review and approval of the Town of Jewett.

15. All landscaping and plantings required for stormwater management systems, drainage filtration strips and/or preservation of freshwater wetlands shall be in accordance with the plans as approved by the Town of Jewett Planning Board. ANY deviation of such shall be presented to the Town (Planning Board, Town Codes Office, Town Engineer, etc.) as appropriate prior to implementing installation.

16. All plantings required for various stormwater management systems shall be maintained in perpetuity by the Developer, the Homeowner Association (HOA) and/or the property owners of each parcel individually or collectively unless changed through legal instrumentation with the Town of Jewett. Any dead or unhealthy plantings, etc., shall be replaced promptly, within the effective, optimum growing season to maintain optimum effective treatment of the system(s).

17. Any construction debris, mud and/or sediment infused stormwater that leaves the Applicant/Development site shall be promptly managed and removed so not to interfere with existing drainage systems on any adjoining public street and/or existing drainage system. Any impacts to area culverts shall be cleaned/cleared and restored to pre-construction conditions in compliance with all applicable NYSDEC, NYCDEP, Greene County Highway, and USACOE

regulations. ALL mud, stone, construction related debris placed on County Route 77 (CR-77) shall be promptly removed by the Applicant/Owner/Developer OR project associated Contractors.

18. Any/all onsite well development shall be in accordance with Town of Jewett, NYSDOH and NYSDEC regulations as they apply.

19. Site and facilities development shall work in cooperation with area Emergency Medical Services and/or Fire Department(s) having jurisdiction / authority to assure effective access and adequate water resources are available for effective fire protection of the development and immediate forestry. New roadway shall be accessible 24/7/365 to all Fire and Emergency Services.

20. All exterior lighting shall be downdirected with light source shielded such that it will face away from residential areas immediate to the Development.

21. Property owners and/or the HOA shall maintain appropriate means of trash removal on a regular basis (not less than weekly). All dumpsters, bins, garbage cans, trash containers, etc. shall be properly secured and properly contained on each parcel to prevent blowing on neighboring properties.

22. If any term or condition of this subdivision or site plan approval is annulled by a court of law, then the Town Board shall retain the right to reconsider whether the approvals meet or exceed the requirements for granting such approvals in accordance with the standards of the Jewett Town Code(s).

23. If any terms and/or conditions of the approvals granted by the Town of Jewett are violated, such violations shall be dealt with in accordance with the Town of Jewett Code(s), including the possibility of revocation of approval by the Court following an adjudication of the violation.

24. Applicant/Developer shall allow Town of Jewett access to the properties and/or site at reasonable times and upon reasonable notice, to evaluate compliance with terms and conditions of approval(s). Town shall appropriately notify APPLICANT of intent to visit the property/site and shall comply with all safety and privacy restrictions applicable to visitors.

25. Access to the Development shall be in accordance with Subdivision for the purpose of review of compliance with such approvals, engineer’s reports, and other documentation approved by the Town of Jewett, including but not limited to any and all plans, reports, stipulated conditions, and/or supplemental documentation.

26. Except where approved for emergency equipment service or notification (i.e., pump or equipment alarms), there will be no outside public address system or amplified music within the Development.

27. No residents shall occupy any parcel or dwelling until Town of Jewett Codes Office has inspected and granted a certificate of occupancy. Temporary Occupancy (tent, camper, RV, lean-to, tiny structure(s), etc.) of any buildable parcel shall be in accordance applicable Local Laws at the time of the occupancy occurrence. There will be no Certificate of Compliance or Occupancy issued until all site improvements have been completed, inspected, and approved by the Town Codes Office.

28. Where/if applicable, all power, CATV, telecommunications and internet services shall be installed within the common rights of way along the new roadway in accordance with Town of Jewett Highway Specifications.

29. The Applicant shall maintain an escrow account in order to reimburse the Town and/or outside Engineering or other Consultants for project review expenses through the completion of the Development.

30. The Applicant shall submit any/all covenants and restrictions as well as a detailed Homeowners Association Plan to the Town for review and acceptance as a condition of FINAL APPROVAL. All terms and conditions shall remain in effect through the FINAL APPROVAL period and remain with the property unless legally amended with the Town of Jewett.

31. Applicant / Developer shall provide an active list of construction and/or appropriate contacts throughout the course of development and/or construction with the Town and Town Codes Office, for drainage management as well as fire and emergency service access.

32. All parcels / lots shall be assigned a E-911 address in accordance with Greene County Emergency Services.

33. Underground Utilities. Where practical, all new utility services should be placed underground.

34. Stormwater Management. Any construction that disturbs soil on any lot within the subdivision is subject to the applicable requirements of the State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (SPDES) administered by the NYSDEC General Permit for Stormwater Discharges From Construction Activities. As a minimum, the owner of each lot and the owner’s designated contractor are responsible for developing and following an Erosion and Sediment Control (ESC) Plan and filing a notice of intent with NYSDEC and/or NYCDEP. A copy of a Sample ESC Plan will be provided by the Developer or his/her Representative to the initial buyer of each lot in the subdivision for their information. It is the lot owner’s sole responsibility to prepare the ESC Plan specific to their proposed construction and to comply with the applicable requirements of the SPDES General Permit.

35. Additionally, prior to final subdivision approval the applicant is required to provide a performance bond in a form acceptable to the Attorney for the Town and the Town Board in an amount acceptable to the Town Engineer to cover the cost of all required improvements. Those required improvements include the construction and/or maintenance of the private road, driveways, and drainage facilities.

36. Approval is also conditioned upon the Applicant making the appropriate filing for the Homeowners Association (HOA) with the NYS Attorney General’s Office in accordance with the NYS General Business Law regarding a ‘de minimus cooperative interest’, if same is appropriate and acceptable to the NYS Attorney General’s Office, with copies of the documentation provided to the Town of Jewett.

37. Approval is further conditioned upon the inclusion of language previously submitted to the Board in all deeds for parcels affected by a private road or driveway setting for the duties and obligations of each owner with regard to maintenance and other issues affecting such driveway and/or road.

R:\2022115\CORR\006R3\Conditions of Approval – Final (TGR_ 5-31-23 (dvd)

SCHEDULE B &C IS ATTACHED AT THE END OF MINUTES

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried, the board moved to authorize Chair Schobel to sign the maps at a later date based on approval from Tal Rappleyea, Esq.

Agenda Item 4: Review of Solar Moratorium

No review was done.

Agenda Item 5: Other Business

There was no other business that came before the board.

Agenda Item 6: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

There being no other business, Mr. Hopstock made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 8:56pm.

_____Barbara Schobel__________Planning Board Chair

_____Maya Carl_______________Planning Board Secretary

Documents

Schedule B (PDF – 5.0 MB)
Schedule B
Schedule C (PDF – 849.2 KB)
Schedule C

Added: June 28, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm.

Present: Deputy Chair Donna Bernard, Members Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and
Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: None
Public Present: Bill Rod.

Agenda Item 2: Approval of the Minutes for April 6, 2023

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of April 6, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Review of Solar Moratorium

The board re-reviewed their first review of the Solar Moratorium law to tighten up any loose ends. The intent of the board is to allow responsible commercial solar but to keep it in line with the town’s comprehensive plan. The beauty, rural character, environmental protection and open spaces were important to the board as each member contributed their thoughts and made grammatical edits.

While doing the review, some questions arose. One of them was regarding renewals. Who will keep track of the Solar Farm 3 year period to renew? Will it be the planning board or the building inspector? What percentage of a bond will the town require? Will it be 125%?

Will this percentage stay the same or be increased during the annual review of the farm?

Chair Schobel will reach out to the supervisor to ask these questions. Once those questions are answered, the planning board will vote to make their official recommendations to the town board.

Agenda Item 6: Other Business

There was no other business that came before the board.

Agenda Item 7: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

There being no other business, Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 9:04pm.

________________________________

Planning Board Chair

________________________________

Planning Board Secretary

Added: May 11, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm.

Present: Deputy Chair Donna Bernard, Members Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and
Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: None
Public Present: Doug Van Deusen of LaMont Engineers, Ryan Cornelison of Stinemire Engineering and Greg Kroyer.

Agenda Item 2: Approval of the Minutes for March 2, 2023

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of March 2, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Public Hearing for Major Subdivision Birch Woods Subdivision for
Parcel ID # 129.00-3-4, 68.60 acres, Rural Residential, owned by Ferdinand Kuznik, represented by Ryan Cornelison, P.E. of Stinemire Engineering.

Ryan Cornelison of Stinemire Engineering reviewed the modifications to the drawings as submitted on 3/29/23 and spoke of the amended stormwater management and septic design items as discussed in the NYCDEP correspondence. Also discussed was the April 6th, 2023 NYCDEP correspondence pertaining to the Notice of Complete Application (NOCA) for the SWPPP and Septic System (SSTS). There is a similar letter for the septic system (SSTS). As noted in the DEP letter, Stinemire Engineering shall submit any modifications to the design to DEP prior to 5/21/2023, the date that DEP has to respond with any further comments concerning the design(s) for the stormwater and/or septic system.

Discussions were had regarding the location and length of the drainage system components and the fact that the Town Highway Department does not have any equipment that could possibly maintain any of the pipes that exceed 30-40 ft. in length. The board also discussed drainage systems at/along the common property lines and whether Stinemire Engineering should consider making any length adjustments to assure they won’t adversely affect any onsite septic system and/or the site development for any new home, NOR adversely impact a neighboring property. With the addition of the 3rd bio-retention basin, they have lessened the concentration of drainage flows into the previous 2-basins, and thereby lessening the discharge(s) along the common property lines and downslope to the neighbors.

There was quite a bit of discussion concerning the “ownership and maintenance” of the stormwater system components and WHO would be the “responsible party” that will forever be the custodian of any part thereof starting from DAY-ONE. Mr. Cornelison also clearly understands that the new roadway will be designed and constructed in accordance with the current Town Highway Specifications. HOWEVER, that does not assure, nor guarantee the Owner/Developer that the “OFFER” for dedication into the Town Highway System will be accepted. The offer will be reviewed by the governing body at that time and determine if the town is financially fit to take on any new roads. The cost of equipment, fuel and labor and the fiscal resources (CHIPS, tax revenue, etc.) may not allow the addition of any new roads, etc. for Highway Department operation and maintenance. The message was quite clear concerning the stormwater and roadway obligations to the Owner / Developer. Mr. Cornelison also understood that he still needs to discuss the roadway design with the Town Highway Superintendent, Robert Mallory so that ANY further tweaks of the roadway design and/or construction are acceptable to the Highway Superintendent and will be incorporated into the FINAL DESIGN.

Mr. Cornelison commented that the Developer’s Attorney and the Town’s Attorney,

Tal Rappleyea Esq., have been in contact with regards to the HOA, covenants and/or restrictions that will be submitted for town review and acceptance. The board briefly discussed some of the “CONDITIONS OF FINAL APPROVAL” that the town has been working on but did not share them with Stinemire Engineering at the meeting. It is hoped that this part of the project review can be ready for discussion at the May meeting. The May 21, 2023 date for DEP to response to Stinemire Engineering on DEP’s review of the SWPPP and SSTS will be AFTER the next regular Town Planning Board meeting. Until the HOA, Covenants and/or Restrictions as well as the roadway maintenance agreement understood to be forthcoming from the Developer, it’s unlikely that the project will be ready for “Final Approval discussion” at the regular May Planning Board meeting.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously, The Planning Board acknowledged that there were no further Lead Agency interests or responses (re: nothing from Greene County Planning, Greene County Highway Department, or NYSDEC) as a follow-up to the February 2023 meeting and therefore revisited SEQR and reaffirmed the Negative Declaration.

ROLL CALL VOTE: AYE Chair Schobel, AYE Deputy Chair Bernard, AYE Member LaPierre,

AYE Member Williams, AYE Member Hopstock.

It was acknowledged that there were no further comments expressed in person or written by any neighbors, and that there was no one attending the meeting to express any issues or concerns for the project review record. It was further acknowledged that the 3/29/2023 revisions submitted appear to address the concerns expressed by the town as well as issues expressed by the neighbors relative to drainage management, acknowledgement of the SWPPP and SSTS comments from NYCDEP and Wetland comments from the Army Corps of Engineers.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously, The Planning Board closed public hearing no. 1 at 9:13pm and voted to accept the Preliminary Plan for parcel ID 129.00-3-4 with the revisions as submitted with the understanding that there are design elements that are still under review by NYCDEP, and that the HOA, Covenants and Deed Restrictions are still in development which shall be addressed and accepted PRIOR TO FINAL APPROVAL.

Agenda Item 6: Other Business

There was no other business that came before the board.

Agenda Item 7: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

There being no other business, Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 9:27pm.

________________________________

Planning Board Chair

________________________________

Planning Board Secretary

Added: April 20, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm.

Present: Members Donna Bernard, Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: None
Public Present: Doug Van Deusen of LaMont Engineers, Ryan Cornelison of Stinemire Engineering, Greg Kroyer, Bill and Carolyn Rod, Paul and Sheila Trautman, Lori Valentini-Galgano, Brando and Ness Rispo, Anatoly Takarev, Jason Winocour, Marc Galgano, Brian Condon, Esq. and Max Peskowitz.

Agenda Item 2: Approval of the Minutes for February 2, 2023

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of February 2, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Public Hearing for Major Subdivision Birch Woods Subdivision for
Parcel ID # 129.00-3-4, 68.60 acres, Rural Residential, owned by Ferdinand Kuznik, represented by Ryan Cornelison, P.E. of Stinemire Engineering.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried the board moved to open the public hearing at 7:45pm.

Comments were made concerning extensive and/or clear-cutting of trees, particularly on lots 10, 11, and 12 to achieve a view of Hunter Mountain Ski Area, etc.

(NOTE: The current Town Code (Ref., Section 140-29) has a stipulated limit of not greater than 50% of the timber cover can be removed without penalty.)

Concern was that tree cutting would lessen the stability of the sloped area to the south and the soils ability to manage drainage run-off. Section 140-29 also stipulates design responsibility of upstream and downstream run-off for pre- and post-development conditions.

Comments and concerns were made relative to existing run-off in the aforementioned area when there is a heavy snowpack and/or heavy rain event. Neighbors question whether the proposed storm water management practices will be effective once the roadway and new homes are in place. What happens after the fact if the proposed practices are not effective?

(NOTE: Current Local Law as well as NYCDEP Watershed Rules and Regulations require onsite storm water management upstream AND downstream of the project site such that storm water run-off cannot exceed the pre-construction conditions and also has a stipulated water quality requirement enforceable under the NYCDEP, NYSDEC and US Army Corps of Engineers rules and regulations.)

Great concerns were voiced over an HOA being the custodial manager of the storm water management systems, worrying that the HOA will default and defacto property owners will shred their deeded responsibilities causing the ultimate responsibility to come to the town and town taxpayers; citing that there is no guarantee that the HOA will perform their duties. Suggestions included a long-term funding resource be established (perhaps “bonding”) so that funding will be available for the town to obtain the necessary people to address the storm water and/or drainage issues. Surrounding neighbors were not comfortable with the default responsibilities being transferred to the development property owners. Questions arose of “What if some or all property owners say they aren’t assuming the financial responsibilities?” and “What legal instrument forces the property owners to participate?”

(NOTE: Town Attorney and town will develop stipulated conditions as part of the final plat approval, whereby the property owners will assume full HOA responsibilities upon default of the HOA. Uncertain if a performance bond or letter of credit or money in escrow can be made part of the final project approval. This requires consultations with the Town Attorney.)

With 11 +/- new homes, the ambient noise level will undoubtedly increase. A question was asked if there is any way the developer can impose restrictions to control noise that may develop from renters and/or partying owners.

(NOTE: Town Code Section 105-5 has specific stipulations and restrictions against operating noise generating equipment between 9 pm and 7 am Monday thru Friday and 9 pm and 8 am on weekends and legal holidays. There are similar restrictions and penalties for construction and demolition activities.)

Similarly, the same concern was voiced with increased lighting with regards to affecting the dark-sky conditions that the neighbors currently enjoy.

(NOTE: There will be conditions imposed as part of the project approval that will require sharp cut-off and/or shielded lighting that forces garage, pole lights and/or exterior wall lights to be down-shining fixtures.)

There was discussion of the proposed project complying with the Town Comprehensive Plan. Based on the current Town Comp Plan (dated October 2007) the project is consistent with adjacent parcels from previous real estate subdivisions, with lots being generally larger than minimum lot sizes and minimizing impacts on natural resources such as freshwater wetlands and timber covered areas to remain. General development will be directed to the more open areas to lessen the effects on standing timber in accordance with the aforementioned Town Code.

A comment was made … “More Homes will bring more people” … “more people will mean more traffic and CR-77 is not in very good condition”.

(NOTE: A traffic study was not conducted by the developer or his Engineer. However, referencing the Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) 5th edition Trip Generation Handbook, the average weekday peak hour could be approx. 0.74 trips per dwelling and approx. 0.76 trips per peak hour on weekends. Such will be well within the design capacity of CR-77.)

County Route 77 is in very bad condition ever since the County Highway took over maintenance and plowing. There is concern that with an additional 11 +/- new homes the road conditions will further deteriorate.

(NOTE: Perhaps with additional new homes on CR-77, Greene Co. Hwy Dept may see the need to improve the roadway conditions and provide additional maintenance and plowing due to increase usage and additional bus traffic.)

Has any hydrogeologic testing been performed to determine if the aquifer can sustain an additional 11 +/- new homes?

Hydrogeologic testing has not been performed by the developer. However, there was considerable discussion concerning an m aquifer study performed within the town several years ago. According to a study conducted by Greene Co. Planning & Development in 2002, there appears to be a water resource that runs through the mid-section of the town and near the general vicinity of the project. According to the study, it appears to be capable of yields of around 10-gal/s per minute or 14,400 GPD. The proposed demand by the proposed project is around 3,630 GPD; approx. 25% of the estimated aquifer yield. Well development records are available through NYSDEC as each well driller is required to register each new well developed per the NYSDEC protocol.

Discussion concerning “clear-cutting” of trees on lots 10, 11, and 12 to enhance their view of Hunter Mountain and the Catskill Mountain Valley. Much concern that removing the trees will exacerbate an erosion condition that will result in serious drainage and run-off onto the southerly neighbor (Valentini). Neighbors are very concerned that the HOA will not be and/or act responsibly; concerned that there won’t be a valid successor to the HOA if they default. Town Code Section 140-28 describes the responsibilities of the developer to address upstream and downstream conditions prior to final approval.

Discussions were had with the Town Highway Superintendent concerning Operation & Maintenance of the bio retention basins and related components. Stipulated conditions as to O & M will be part of the conditions for Final Approval. Further discussions between Town Highway Supt. Mallory and Stinemire Engineering Rep – Ryan Cornelison concerning a 214-ft long, 24-inch diameter drainage pipe from an overflow structure to an outfall on the common property line with Lots 11 & 12. Discussions with Stinemire Engineering indicated that they would place a manhole or other similar type structure to allow the highway department access for thawing the drainage pipe during the winter months. The span between the structures is approx. 70-ft as that is the longest the town highway can reach with their current deicing equipment. The outfall is on the common property line and directs outfall directly downslope towards the southerly neighbor (Valentini) with a means of treating or managing the outfall indicated. How will this be addresses/managed?

Developer still has not defined who will be the “owner” of Lot # 8 the unbuildable wetlands. Town Code section 140-29 describes as a condition of approval; the Town shall receive 3% of the total assessed value of the entire parcel as fee that will/can be used to maintain other existing recreational areas in the town without creating an additional area at this project site.

Also, in Town Code section 140-29 – Preservation of Natural Features … the maximum allowable tree / timber removal is 50% without the approval of the Town Planning Board for additional trees / timber removal.

Chair Schobel stated that THE PUBLIC HEARING AND COMMENT PERIOD WILL REMAIN OPEN UNTIL THE NEXT REGULAR TOWN PLANNING BOARD MEETING WHICH IS SCHEDULED FOR APRIL 6, 2023.

Chair Schobel made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried, the board moved to do a preliminary review of part 2 of the SEQR review and afterwards did a preliminary review of part 3 SEQR review, the determination of significance.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to declare a negative declaration.

Roll Call: AYE, Schobel, Bernard, LaPierre, Williams and Hopstock.

Agenda Item 6: Other Business

There was no other business that came before the board.

Agenda Item 7: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

There being no other business, Mr. Hopstock made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 10:33pm.

________________________________

Planning Board Chair

________________________________

Planning Board Secretary

Added: March 15, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm.

Present: Members Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: Member Donna Bernard
Public Present: Doug Van Deusen of LaMont Engineers, Ryan Cornelison and John Stinemire of Stinemire Engineering, Darrin Elsom, PE of Kaaterskill Associates and Greg Kroyer.

Agenda Item 2: Approval of the Minutes for January 5, 2023

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of January 5, 2023.

Agenda Item 3: Public Hearing for Yellow Pine Management, LLC for
Tax ID 147.00-1-17 (10.8 acres), 18 (1.50 acres) & 19 (2.30 acres). Route 23A, North side of road opposite of Maplewood Cemetery, Rural Conservation. Owned by Greg Haefelin, represented by Darrin Elsom, PE of Kaaterskill Associates.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried the board moved to open the public hearing at 8:15pm.

There was no public comment.

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried the board moved to close the public hearing at 8:15pm.

Agenda Item 3: Application for Minor Subdivision Yellow Pine Management, LLC for
Tax ID 147.00-1-17 (10.8 acres), 18 (1.50 acres) & 19 (2.30 acres). Route 23A, North side of road opposite of Maplewood Cemetery, Rural Conservation. Owned by Greg Haefelin, represented by Darrin Elsom, PE of Kaaterskill Associates.

Mr. Elsom presented to the board all that they had required of him from the last meeting, the letter of representation, resolving the matter of merging the properties together before or after which he did find out from Greene County that he could do it all when he goes to file the map. Mr. Elsom produced a road maintenance agreement, the SHPO letter, mylar map, seven paper copies and the additional fee.

The board then reviewed comments received from Cynthia Garcia, SEQRA coordinator stating the DEP does not object to the Board acting as Lead Agency for the coordinated review of the proposed action pursuant to the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA). The board did a preliminary review last month regarding part 1 and 2 of the SEQR review. The board then reviewed part 3, the determination of significance.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously, the board moved to declare a negative declaration.

Roll Call: AYE, Schobel, LaPierre, Williams and Hopstock. Absent was Ms. Bernard.

Mr. Hopstock made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously the board moved to approve Yellow Pine Management, LLC’s Application for Minor Subdivision for Tax ID 147.00-1-17 (10.8 acres), 18 (1.50 acres) & 19 (2.30 acres)with the following conditions,

“Declaration as to common unity and access easement and driveway maintenance on lands of Yellow Pine Management, LLC must be fully executed.”

Roll Call: AYE, Schobel, LaPierre, Williams and Hopstock. Absent was Ms. Bernard.

Agenda Item 4: Application for Major Subdivision, Birchwoods Subdivision,
Parcel ID # 129.00-3-4, 68.60 acres, Rural Residential, owned by Ferdinand Kuznik, represented by Ryan Cornelison, P.E. of Stinemire Engineering.

The Board revisited/recapped the October 6, 2022 meeting such that the meeting record of October 6, 2022 reflects that the Planning Board accepted the application for the Birch Woods Major Subdivision.

Based on the materials submitted, Mr. Lapierre made a motion, seconded by Mr. Hopstock and carried the board voted to accept the submission for Sketch Plan in accordance with Article II, Section # 140-9 of the Town Code that was submitted on October 6, 2022.

ROLL CALL: Schobel-AYE, LaPierre-AYE, Williams-NAY, Hopstock-AYE. Member Bernard was absent.

At the October 6, 2022 meeting, the application was classified as a “MAJOR SUBDIVISION” and will be required to comply with Article IV, Sections 140-15 thru 140-20, as well as applicable sections pertaining to the new roadway, etc. As with most Major Subdivisions, a Full EAF (FEAF) will be (and has been) prepared.

In accordance with SEQR, the Town Planning Board classified the project as an UNLISTED ACTION and the Planning Board wants to be Lead Agency. Because NYCDEP, Greene Co. Highway and NYCDEC & US Army Corps will be involved agencies (those that will issue permits for some aspect of the project), there will be a “Coordinated Review”, such that the involved agencies will be asked to provide their review comments prior to the PB issuing final approval. The letters going out to notify the agencies of the Town’s desire to be Lead Agency, will request that any review comments be sent as soon as possible so that they can be integrated with the Planning Boards review.

Brief review of FEAF part-1 was done with Planning Board. FEAF Part-2 and Part-3 will be reviewed at the next Planning Board Meeting.

The materials submitted under the Stinemire Engineering cover letter of January 10, 2023 pertain to the preliminary plan submission and so acknowledged by the Planning Board. Subdivision plans, details, etc. will be required to comply with applicable sections of Article IV – Major Subdivision, Section # 140-15 thru 140-20 and Article VI Sections # 140-24 thru 140-29 as it pertains to the Major Subdivision and design and dedication of the new roadway.

The Planning Board went over comments and discussion items reflected in Lamont Engineers project review letter dated January 26, 2023 and discussion of materials submitted by Stinemire Engineering.

Discussion was also had of edits to the FEAS regarding the correct name of Owner of Record, address of Owner, etc.

The Planning Board discussed design and construction of the new roadway; procedure for dedication of the roadway, including requirements of at least 3-homes per ½-mile of roadway per Town Code # 140-26 (J). Discussion included width of the Right Of Way (ROW) with a minimum width of 50-ft that may not be adequate to include all portions of the roadway that will be under the maintenance of the Town Highway Department upon formal dedication. Based on areas that will be graded for construction of the roadway and drainage system(s), it appears that the 50-ft wide ROW will not encompass all areas that the developer would like to be maintained by the Town. With that said, it was suggested that the Consultant review the possibility of a wider ROW so that all ditch lines and drainage systems would be within the area to be dedicated to reduce / eliminate the need for permanent easements.

Discussion was had on who will maintain the roadway corridor, drainage systems and freshwater wetlands throughout construction and project development, as well as the non-buildable status of Lot No. 8 and associated freshwater wetlands and water body. Mr. Stinemire discussed the possibility of creating a Home-Owners Association (HOA) for the temporary maintenance of the roadway until ready for dedication, as well as forming the HOA so that Lot No. 8 would remain “Open Space” with no hardscapes and minimal disturbance in placement of recreational amenities such as picnic tables, etc., and the possibility of offering it to the Town for recreational use by the lot owners and possibly OTHERS as a “Common Area”. Much discussion was had on the issue. Mr. Stinemire will review options with the Owner(s), with the understanding that the Town has NO DESIRE to accept, own, or maintain a recreation area.

Mr. Stinemire discussed the “minimum roadway standards” stated in Section # 140-26, particularly the width of the travel lane and shoulders. The applicant has indicated the desire to have 10-ft wide travel lanes but would like to adjust the shoulder width from 5-ft to something narrower. Since this is part of the Town Code, the applicant will need to make a written request for any adjustment to the Town Local Law for review and decision. It was further discussed that Mr. Stinemire would review the request with the Town Highway Superintendent as he will ultimately determine if a narrower shoulder would impede his ability to properly maintain the roadway during inclement winter weather conditions. It was discussed that the overall width of roadway (travel area) should not be less than 28-ft as shown in the Code. Mr. Stinemire will review this further with the owner and Town Highway Superintendent for further discussion at the next Planning Board meeting.

Mr. Stinemire will work on covenants, easements, and dead restrictions, if any, that the developer will want to enforce on the project. A draft of these items will be submitted for Town and Town Attorney review as the project progresses through the Preliminary Plan review.

Discussions were had of NYCDEP letters dated Jan. 30, 2023 with regards to Storm water Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) and Sanitary Wastewater disposal. Stinemire Engineering will review the items in the DEP letters and report at the next Planning Board meeting. NYCDEP is requesting grading for each of the proposed lots be shown to determine if the affected areas shown on Sheet C-103 is accurate or if grading will exceed the approximate limits indicated. Since this is not a “Realty Subdivision and the actual placement of each home, garage, well, leach field, etc. is uncertain, Mr. Stinemire feels this level of detailing should not be required of this project. Consultant will discuss the SWPPP comment letter further with NYCDEP and discuss with the Planning Board at the next meeting.

Discussions were also had of what information will be on the plan sheet(s) that will ultimately be submitted for Planning Board Plat approval and ultimately filed in The Greene County Clerk’s office. Consultant suggested that perhaps all (15 +/-) sheets may be submitted for Planning Board approval and signature, and Green County filing.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, seconded by Mr. Williams and carried, the board moved to hold a public hearing for an Application for Major Subdivision for Birchwoods Subdivision, Parcel ID # 129.00-3-4, 68.60 acres, Rural Residential, owned by Ferdinand Kuznik, represented by Ryan Cornelison, P.E. of Stinemire Engineering to be held on March 2, 2023 at 7:45pm at the Jewett Municipal Building with conditions of the meeting stated below.

After reviewing the application, FEAF, plans, details, and questions / comments, etc. the Board determined the Preliminary Plan as submitted was detailed enough to schedule at least the first Public Hearing for March 2nd, 2023, with the understanding that the Public Hearing will remain OPEN until all questions and comments from the Involved Agencies, Co. Planning under GML-239, etc. are in the file and that edits to the plans and/or details are addressed and further discussion concerning the HOA and how the ownership of Lot No. 8 and the Wetlands will be addressed, and ANY comments/concerns arising from the Public during the hearing, giving the public ample time to respond either in person, emails or letters, etc. It was further understood that this may take a couple of months to complete. Based on the response from the 1st public hearing, the Planning Board will determine if a 2nd Public Hearing will be necessary, with the Applicant possibly requesting a waiver for the 2nd Hearing.

Agenda Item 4: Other Business

There was no other business that came before the board.

Agenda Item 5: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

There being no other business, Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 10:56pm.

________________________________

Planning Board Chair

________________________________

Planning Board Secretary

Added: February 09, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm.

Present: Members Donna Bernard, Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: None
Public Present: Darrin Elsom, PE of Kaaterskill Associates and Greg Kroyer.

Agenda Item 2: Approval of the Minutes for December 1, 2022

Mr. Williams made a motion, 2nd by Mr. LaPierre and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of December 1, 2022.

Agenda Item 3: Application for Minor Subdivision Yellow Pine Management, LLC for
Tax ID 147.00-1-17 (10.8 acres), 18 (1.50 acres) & 19 (2.30 acres). Route 23A, North side of road opposite of Maplewood Cemetery, Rural Conservation. Owned by Greg Haefelin, represented by Darrin Elsom, PE of Kaaterskill Associates.

Mr. Elsom of Kaaterskill Associates took the floor and explained that his client is trying to bring his 3 parcels into conformity. He is looking to subdivide the 3 existing lots into 2 lots with new proposed property lines. The first to be 5.74+- acres and the second lot 7.73+- acres which would absorb the current 2.3 acres (parcel #147.00-1-19). Chair Schobel asked how they were planning on removing the existing lot lines. Mr. Elson said that if he had a subdivision plat signed by a surveyor and by the Planning Board Chair that it should happen when they go to file the map with Greene County. Mr. Elson went on to say that he believes it is not necessary to merge them first before the subdivision and that when he goes to file, they will see the new property lines then and make the adjustments accordingly. He said he will speak with his surveyor to confirm this. Ms. Bernard said that in the past, the board always had the applicant do a lot line adjustment before the application for the minor subdivision and said that they have never approved a subdivision unless there were two legal parcels.

Mr. Elson then asked if the town had a lot line adjustment law and was told yes by the board.

Mr. Elson said he will follow what the board would like him to do. Chair Schobel said the board would like to proceed with the minor subdivision application but would like him to check with Greene County office of Real Property Tax Service very soon and that if this is ok with them, then we can proceed. The board agreed that it was a pretty straight forward application and they were happy that the owner was bringing it into conformity. Looking at the site plan, Ms. Bernard commented that she didn’t like seeing all those long driveways but felt with the steep elevation that there was no other way to do it. Mr. Elsom agreed. Ms. Bernard said the intention of the board is to disturb as little as possible and in considering the topography of the one lot, there is no other way to access the areas that are buildable and support the septic system. Mr. Hopstock asked why the upper part of the driveway was not more direct instead of having many curves. Mr. Elsom said the owner wanted it that way so he could enter in from the back of the house. Chair Schobel said she would like it to be made contingent on having a deeded right of way for the proposed driveway as well as a road maintenance agreement so that in the future and even now there will be no issues with who is going to maintain the driveway. Mr. Elsom agreed. He then went on to say that on the EAF, they got flagged for being in an area of archeological significance. They hired a cultural consultant who did a phase one archeological and found nothing. They will have SHPO (State Historic Preservation Office) sign off on the report.

The board reviewed the application for a minor subdivision. The letter of representation was missing and Mr. Elsom agreed to e-mail it to the planning board secretary.

It was found that the application was in order along with the SEQRA part 1 being completed. The board then did a preliminary review for SEQR part 2. Mr. Elsom paid $200 and was told that the fee for a minor subdivision is $500 and a sketch plan review is $250. Mr. Elsom said he would bring $550 to the next meeting. The board agreed and then instructed the secretary to send the referral to Cynthia Garcia, SEQR Coordinator.

Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously,

the board moved to declare lead agency status for this unlisted action.

Ms. Bernard made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Williams and carried unanimously, the board moved to go forward with a public hearing for a minor subdivision for Yellow Pine Management LLC at the next planning board meeting which is scheduled for February 2, 2023 at 8pm.

The secretary will place a legal ad in the Mountain Eagle regarding the public hearing.

Chair Schobel then furnished Mr. Elsom with all the paperwork he would need for the next meeting. He was given the public hearing sign, along with instructions on how to post and a letter form that is to be sent to adjoining property owners thru certified mail regarding the Subdivision Public Hearing. Mr. Elsom received a certification form of posting public hearing notice sign and a certification form of mailing notices of public hearing to adjoining property owners.

Mr. Elsom then confirmed with the board everything he would need for the next meeting: Letter of representation, resolving the matter of merging the properties together before or after, road maintenance agreement, having the SHPO letter, mylar map, seven paper copies and the additional fee.

The board agreed. Ms. Bernard then stated if the county wants the dissolved lines done before we do anything, we can do this before the meeting and asked Mr. Elsom to come a little earlier.

Agenda Item 4: Solar Moratorium Review

The Planning Board continued their review of regulating solar energy systems.

They reviewed pages 11-15. The planning board will be reviewing pages 16- the end at the next meeting scheduled for February 2, 2023. Homework given was to read the NYS Solar application and review the NY State Unified Solar Permit.

Agenda Item 4: Other Business

The board reviewed maps and paperwork of an upcoming case regarding a proposed major subdivision.

Agenda Item 5: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

There being no other business, Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Mr. Hopstock and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 9:23pm.

________________________________

Planning Board Secretary

Added: January 06, 2023

Agenda Item 1: Call to Order and Roll Call

Planning Board Chair, Barbara Schobel called the meeting to order at 7:31 pm.

Present: Members Donna Bernard, Paul LaPierre, Simon Williams and Christopher Hopstock.
Maya Carl, Planning Board Secretary.
Absent: None
Public Present: None

Agenda Item 2: Approval of the Minutes for November 3, 2022

Mr. Paul LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously, the board moved to accept the minutes of November 3, 2022.

Agenda Item 3: Solar Moratorium Review

The Planning Board continued their review of regulating solar energy systems.

They reviewed pages 6-11. The planning board will be reviewing pages 11-15 at the next meeting scheduled for January 5, 2023 and homework given was to review the NY State Unified Solar Permit.

Agenda Item 4: Other Business

The board reviewed maps and paperwork of an upcoming case regarding a proposed minor subdivision.

Agenda Item 5: Greene County Planning Board

No meeting held.

There being no other business, Mr. LaPierre made a motion, 2nd by Ms. Bernard and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 9:39pm.

________________________________

Planning Board Secretary